These are some of the places near Rumagin Villa that are recommended
The Fish Pot – Tel. No. 635 1728
This is a friendly local restaurant at the bottom of the hill as you go down to Stonehaven Beach from Rumagin Villa.
If you want a starter, try either their crab cakes or Jerk fish and then you can have their catch of the day as your main course. They often have Barracuda, Mahi Mahi or Red Snapper, normally accompanied by a salad or potato wedges. The seating is outside on a small covered verandah.
The Paradise Grill – Tel no. 322-9441 or 344-1703
The Paradise Grill is a small restaurant on the road to Pigeon Point so you have to book in advance. They do superb lobster and if you get your timing right you can often see a beautiful sunset as you sit on the small verandah. Take your own alcohol (and insect repellant) and be aware that high seas can sometimes cause last minute cancellations.

The Waves Beach Bar, Old Grafton Road, Stonehaven Bay – Tel. no. 639 4369
You can get a light lunch or a drink at this beach bar which is right on the beach at Stonehaven
Bay, but you may find service is a bit slow.